Digger magazine

Serving the Northwest Nursery Industry for Over 50 Years

  • Farwest-50th-banner-DM.com-728x90-1.jpg
  • NGW-728x90-v2.png
  • Digger-Employment_banner-2020-728x90px.jpg
  • NG-Survey-banner-728x90-1.jpg
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Nursery News
    • Features
    • Plants
    • Growing Knowledge
    • Operations
    • Nursery Country
  • Issues
  • Events
  • Farwest
  • Columns
    • Director’s Desk
    • Mike Darcy
    • Pivot Points
    • President’s Message
  • Employment Classifieds
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe to Digger
You are here: Home / Columns / Pushing back on the unworkable

Pushing back on the unworkable

By Jeff Stone — Posted June 22, 2022

Worker safety is critical, and nursery and greenhouse operations make it a priority.

Our industry has learned a lot from the dynamic and harsh weather events of the past year. But Oregon agriculture has been put back on its heels by a new set of heat and smoke rules, created under pressure from labor and farmworker advocates. These rules seem to carry a presumption that employers are careless with workers’ safety, when that’s not the case. Growers have every interest in protecting their workers, not to mention that it’s the right thing to do.

These latest rules, created by the Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Administration (Oregon OSHA), create problems rather than solving them, while exposing regulators’ unfamiliarity with ag.

What is rulemaking?

Oregon OSHA works for the governor. The agency is responsible for creating and enforcing the standards for which businesses must adhere to on a certain topic.

In administrative law, rulemaking is the process that executive and independent agencies use to create, or promulgate, regulations. In general, legislatures first set broad policy mandates by passing statutes, then agencies create more detailed regulations through rulemaking. To topline it, they take policy and grind it into a set of rules.

I have participated in numerous rulemaking committees on behalf of our industry. It’s almost always grueling, and often appalling to witness. Political agendas are out for all to see.

Currently, the OAN advocacy team is engaged in 45 different rulemaking processes, but not really by choice. If we aren’t there, our voice disappears.

Our usual approach is threefold: 1) push for common sense, 2) make sure rules don’t exceed the intent of the legislation, and 3) work diligently to curtail expansive administrative policies by state agencies.

Over the past decade, the OAN has earned some landmark legislative victories. We secured estate tax reform, won support for water supply programs, and secured unanimous passage of a law preventing county assessors from taxing hoop houses to the tune of $2,000 per structure.

But aside from the hoop house law, these wins didn’t end up being wins. They became victims of the rulemaking process. The people who opposed our bills were able to harm the intent of the legislation by making it overly complex, and no longer helpful to our cause. No wonder I often say that rulemaking is where good bills go to die.

Why OSHA rules miss the mark

Oregon OSHA’s new heat and smoke rules don’t just miss the mark, they miss the boat. The “heat dome” weather event the state experienced last summer devastated operations, and our industry was tremendously saddened by the death of a worker at a nursery operation.

Climate models show we could have another hot summer. We need clear guidelines for agricultural producers. In fact, we welcome the opportunity to talk about the good practices employed to protect workers.

Unfortunately, Oregon OSHA set out trying to write the most aggressive heat and smoke rules in the country. The rules are completely unworkable, and the OAN and other industries have been pounding the table to shrugging shoulders.

To name a few examples, the trigger for heat illness prevention methods begins at 79 F, and operations could be cited when the heat index surpasses 80 F. Those apply indoors and out.

If an employer fails to provide adequate shade or access to water, especially as the temperature creeps above 90 F, the violation is quite serious.

OSHA does not have the authority to push wage rules, but let us not get too comfortable that the public relations factor does not put ag in a bad light. Many of the proponents of the restrictive rule pushed for employees to be sent home when 90 F is hit — with pay. 

Proponents often cast aspersions that growers treat their employees with complete disregard for their health and safety. We have pushed back hard on these narratives. Oregon ag workers are used to working hard, both inside and outside. Temperatures in our fine corner of the country rarely jump to a disastrous level overnight. Workers acclimate naturally.

What is OAN doing

Your OAN leadership is not standing around as this happens. We helped fund a lawsuit to put the OSHA rules on hold. We’re not trying to absolve ourselves of the need to have a plan for heat events.

Rather, we want to reset the discussion, so that rules and enforcement action can be grounded in reality. We are pushing for more oversight by the state legislature. Nobody elected OSHA, and they are operating without much common-sense pushback by the executive branch. OSHA must not overstep its authority.

At the same time, we must educate legislators and the next governor, taking office in 2023, on what our grower community already does to protect workers.

To inform this discussion, I have asked many of our members what they do on hot days. The answers are not really surprising.

They start early and knock off before temperatures hit their peak. They talk to employees about the signs of heat exhaustion and encourage them to watch out for each other, so it can be prevented in real time. Some just send their crews home when it gets past 94 degrees.

But ag work is ag work. It is hard, it is physical, and our workers are good at it. My advice is to have a plan ready for the summer, use common sense like you normally do, and let us hope and pray that we do not see another 117 F day.

Download a PDF of this article.Download

Filed Under: Columns, Director's Desk Tagged With: Digger, Digger magazine, OAN, OAN Members, Politics

About Jeff Stone

Jeff Stone is the executive director of the Oregon Association of Nurseries. He can be reached at 503-682-5089 or jstone@oan.org.

NURSERY NEWS

Darcy added to OSU agricultural Diamond Pioneer Registry

Nursery industry tops list of Oregon ag commodities

Fall Creek promotes Amelie Aust to executive board chair

Hall of Famers give gift towards horticultural industry advocacy

Verl Holden retires from Oregon Garden Foundation Board

More Nursery News

FARWEST SHOW UPDATES

Secure your 2023 Farwest hotel room and save

Farwest Show to celebrate 50th anniversary in 2023

Nursery professionals connect at Farwest

These 12 products had buyers buzzing at Farwest

Nightfall Snowbell sweeps top honors in Farwest New Varieties Showcase

More Updates from Farwest

From the pages of Digger

June 2023: The Shrubs Issue

May 2023: The Sustainability Issue

April 2023: The Trees Issue

March 2023: Water Outlook 2023

February 2023: Greenhouse Issue ’23

More issues of Digger

The Value of Membership

Member Profile: Mahonia Nursery

Meet the Leader: Angela Bailey

OAN Member Profile: Oregon Flowers Inc. 

More member stories

CORONAVIRUS COVERAGE

Virtual is the new reality – for now

Trade shows in the time of COVID

A demand ‘renaissance’ for nurseries

Western Nursery & Landscape Association falls victim to pandemic

MANTS 2021 to move online due to COVID-19

More articles

Nursery Guide LIVE

Nursery Guide LIVE clicks into place

Booth spaces still available for Nursery Guide LIVE March 17–18

Nursery Guide LIVE virtual marketplace postponed due to winter storm damage

Keynote presentations at Nursery Guide LIVE virtual marketplace provide insight on green industry trends in 2021 and beyond

More Posts from this Category

​

Updates to exisiting subscriptions can be sent to info@oan.org

News

  • Nursery News
  • Growing Knowledge
  • Nursery Operations

Features

  • Plant Features
  • OAN Members
  • Oregon Nursery Country

Columns

  • Director’s Desk
  • Mike Darcy
  • Pivot Points
  • President’s Message

Resources

  • OAN Home Page
  • Job Listings
  • Subscribe to Digger
  • Advertise in Digger
  • Online Plant Search

© Copyright 2022 Oregon Association of Nurseries · Admin